Every radio programme, television channel and mobile phone call travels on the airwaves: the radio frequencies, or spectrum, that carry signals through the air and down from satellites. Nobody made them and nobody can own them. They belong to the public, and the government holds them in trust.
That is not only a political idea. It is the law of the land. On 9 February 1995, in Ministry of Information and Broadcasting v. Cricket Association of Bengal, the Supreme Court of India held that the airwaves are public property that must be used for the public good. Three decades on, that judgment remains the foundation of every argument for public service broadcasting in India.
“Airwaves constitute public property and must be utilised for advancing public good. No individual has a right to utilise them at his choice and pleasure and for purposes of his choice including profit.”
“The airwaves or frequencies are a public property. Their use has to be controlled and regulated by a public authority in the interests of the public and to prevent the invasion of their rights.”
When this article was first written in 2007, private broadcasters were using that public property largely to make money. That is still true. What has changed is the size of the business, the small number of hands it is held in, and the arrival of new claimants for the same spectrum.
The law since 1995
Since 1995 the rules for handing out the airwaves have changed in three important ways.
- Auction as the rule for commercial use. In February 2012, in the 2G spectrum case, the Supreme Court set aside the first-come-first-served allocation of mobile spectrum and said public auction should be the preferred way to allocate public resources such as spectrum. In April 2024 the Union government asked the Court to clarify that the verdict did not bar assigning spectrum administratively in some cases. The Court’s registry refused to accept the application, treating it as a review in the guise of a clarification, filed almost twelve years late.
- Administrative assignment, written into law. The Telecommunications Act, 2023 lists in its First Schedule 19 uses for which spectrum is assigned by administrative process rather than auction. Public broadcasting services are one. So are community radio and satellite services, including television channels, teleports and DTH.
- Satellite internet. In September 2026 the Department of Telecommunications’ Digital Communications Commission approved administrative assignment of spectrum to satellite internet operators such as Starlink, Eutelsat OneWeb and Jio’s satellite service, for an initial five years, at 5% of adjusted gross revenue, and one percentage point less for operators serving hard-to-reach areas. The decision still needs the government’s final approval.
So the airwaves are now handed out in two ways: by auction to the highest bidder, or administratively at a price the government sets. Either can serve the public. Neither does so automatically. What matters is whether the terms are open, and whether those who gain from public property give the public something back.
Who uses the airwaves, and on what terms
| User | How they get the airwaves | What they pay | What they owe the public |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mobile operators | Auction, following the 2012 verdict | Their winning bids | No programming obligation |
| Private FM radio | Auction; the third batch of Phase III awarded frequencies in 43 cities in August 2025 | Winning bids, from Rs 29 lakh to Rs 7.83 crore in that batch | At least one hour a day of public service programming, if the June 2026 draft rules are adopted |
| Private satellite TV channels | A government permission; satellite spectrum assigned administratively | Rs 2 lakh a year to uplink and Rs 5 lakh a year to downlink each channel, plus applicable spectrum charges | 30 minutes a day of public service content: optional under the 2022 guidelines, compulsory if the June 2026 draft rules are adopted |
| Satellite internet | Administrative assignment for five years, approved in September 2026 and awaiting final clearance | 5% of adjusted gross revenue, or 4% in hard-to-reach areas | No programming obligation |
| Prasar Bharati | Administrative assignment for public broadcasting services | Funded by a government grant and its own revenue | Its entire mandate under Section 12 of the Prasar Bharati Act |
Read down the last column. Those who use the airwaves to sell advertising have, until now, owed the public only what they chose to give. The one user whose whole purpose is public service is the public broadcaster.
Public property, private profit
Broadcasting has become an industry. Since economic liberalisation, most new entrants have come for profit, riding a consumer culture that the media itself spreads, encourages and exploits. That was our diagnosis in 2007. The numbers since then have only sharpened it.
- Concentration. In November 2024 Reliance and Disney merged their Indian media businesses into JioStar, bringing about 120 television channels and two streaming services under one roof. Reporters Without Borders counts more than 70 media outlets owned by Reliance Industries’ Mukesh Ambani. TRAI recommended limits on cross-media ownership in 2014; the government asked it to reconsider, and in 2022 TRAI went back to asking whether ownership should even be monitored.
- Advertising. Digital platforms took 63% of all advertising spending in India in 2025, up from 50% two years earlier. Television’s advertising revenue fell by more than 10% that year, and pay TV lost 11 million homes. Channels that live on advertising are fighting over a shrinking pool.
- Ratings. Advertisers still buy television by the numbers, and the programmes that draw the biggest audiences, often crime, scandal and shouting matches, win the money. When this article was first written, the editorial director of a leading news channel admitted that when the market and conscience pull in different directions, the market wins.
None of this makes private broadcasters villains. They are doing what businesses do. But the airwaves they use are not their property, and a democracy cannot leave its information to a market that rewards sensation.
What’s wrong with electronic media?
People of every background and political belief worry about electronic media. Citizens complain that news has drifted into infotainment. In 2007 the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting proposed a content code for broadcasters, and the broadcasters resisted it. Nearly two decades later, the same arguments go round.
- Self-regulation without teeth. In August 2023 the Supreme Court questioned whether the Rs 1 lakh maximum fine that the news broadcasters’ own regulator could impose, a limit set in 2008, could deter anyone. Penalties, it said, should be proportionate to the profit a channel makes from the programme, and it asked for the self-regulatory mechanism to be strengthened.
- A law still in draft. The Broadcasting Services (Regulation) Bill was released in draft in November 2023. A second draft was withdrawn in August 2024 after objections. In December 2025 the government told the Rajya Sabha it was still being revised, with no date for its introduction. In June 2026 the ministry proposed a separate single rulebook for TV, radio, DTH and IPTV under the Telecommunications Act.
- Public service by quota. The 2022 uplinking guidelines asked private TV channels to carry 30 minutes a day of content on themes of national importance, such as education, health, agriculture and the environment, on a voluntary, self-certified basis. The June 2026 draft rules would make that compulsory, and add an hour a day for private FM radio. Critics have asked whether editorial independence can survive themes prescribed by the government.
- Ratings reform. In March 2026 the government replaced its 2014 ratings guidelines with a new TV Rating Policy: larger panels of metered homes, no counting of “landing page” viewing, independent directors and regular audits for rating agencies.
- Fakes. In February 2026 the IT Rules were amended to require labels on AI-generated content and much faster takedowns. A flood of fabricated video makes trustworthy news more valuable, and harder to find.
Each of these responds to a symptom. Indecent programmes, unreliable ratings, shouting matches and fake videos grow from the same roots: public airwaves handed to private interests on terms that ask little in return, an advertising market that rewards sensation, ownership concentrated in a few hands, and a public broadcaster that is neither fully funded nor fully independent. Treating one symptom at a time will not cure the disease.
The next contest: broadcast spectrum on your phone
A new claim on the public airwaves is being settled now. Direct-to-mobile (D2M) broadcasting would let phones receive live television and radio over the air, with no internet connection or SIM card, the way a TV set does.
In February 2026 a Committee of Secretaries approved the 470–582 MHz band for D2M under a public–private partnership, and gave Prasar Bharati six months to roll out the first phase. Prasar Bharati has run trials in more than 19 cities with IIT Kanpur, and tests in November 2025 found no harmful interference with mobile networks. Mobile operators, through the Cellular Operators Association of India, oppose the plan: they fear losing video traffic, one of their fastest-growing sources of revenue, and have asked for fresh trials.
This is the question the Supreme Court answered in 1995. Spectrum used to broadcast free to everyone is public property put to public use. It should not be handed to services that charge for every megabyte without a full and open public debate, and the public broadcaster should be at the centre of whatever is built.
Timeline
- The Supreme Court holds that the airwaves are public property.
- Prasar Bharati takes charge of All India Radio and Doordarshan.
- This article is first published.
- The 2G verdict makes public auction the preferred way to allocate spectrum.
- TRAI recommends limits on cross-media ownership.
- New uplinking guidelines ask private TV channels for 30 minutes a day of public service content.
- The draft Broadcasting Services (Regulation) Bill is released.
- The Telecommunications Act lists public broadcasting and satellite TV among uses for administrative assignment.
- The Supreme Court registry rejects the Centre’s plea to modify the 2G verdict.
- Reliance and Disney complete the JioStar merger.
- FM frequencies are auctioned in 43 cities.
- The 470–582 MHz band is cleared for D2M broadcasting. The IT Rules require labels on AI-generated content.
- A new TV Rating Policy replaces the 2014 guidelines.
- Draft rules would make public service programming compulsory for private TV and radio.
- Satellite internet spectrum is approved for administrative assignment at 5% of revenue.
What we ask
Friends of Prasar Bharati calls on the Government of India and Parliament to treat the airwaves as what the Supreme Court said they are: public property, held in trust for the people.
“The Central Government shall take immediate steps to establish an independent autonomous public authority representatives of all sections and interests in the society to control and regulate the use of the airwaves.”
- Open the books on the airwaves. Publish who holds which frequencies, how they were assigned and what they pay, for every user from mobile operators to television channels.
- Ask more of those who profit. Commercial users of public spectrum should give real public value in return, measured and reported in public, without a ministry deciding what goes on air.
- Keep broadcast spectrum for free broadcasting. Protect the UHF band for free-to-air television and D2M, with Prasar Bharati at the centre.
- An independent regulator, as the Court directed. Thirty years after the 1995 judgment, broadcast content is still overseen by a ministry. Parliament should create the independent, representative authority the Court asked for, and debate the long-pending broadcasting law in public.
- Limit concentration. Act on cross-media ownership, so that no single group can dominate what India watches, hears and reads.
- Fund the public broadcaster fully and directly. The surest way to make the airwaves serve the public is a public broadcaster with secure money and secure independence. Read our case for full and direct funding.
Answering the objections
“Spectrum should go to whoever pays the most.”
For many commercial uses, auction is right, and the 2012 verdict says so. But the Telecommunications Act itself recognises that some uses, such as public broadcasting, disaster management and community radio, serve the public better than any bid. The test is not price alone but public value, openly accounted for.
“Public service obligations are just government publicity.”
The risk is real, and critics raised it when the 30-minute rule was proposed. That is why we put independence first: a well-funded, autonomous public broadcaster and an independent regulator, rather than themes chosen by a ministry.
“Everyone has moved online, so the airwaves no longer matter.”
India had 193 million TV homes in 2025, and television still reaches about 745 million people a week. DD FreeDish, which costs nothing to watch, grew to 53 million homes. The online world runs on spectrum too: D2M and satellite internet are fresh claims on the same public airwaves.
“Regulation threatens press freedom.”
The Supreme Court has accepted that broadcasters should not face censorship, while insisting that their self-regulation must actually work. Our concern is independence from government and from owners alike. An independent regulator protects press freedom better than a ministry, or no one, can.
Conclusion
The airwaves belong to you. Everyone who uses them, for any purpose, is a guest on public property.
In 2007 we argued that the troubles of Indian electronic media had structural causes, and that fixing one symptom at a time would not cure them. Nearly twenty years on, the structure is plainer than ever: spectrum assigned on terms that ask little of commercial users, a market that rewards sensation, ownership in fewer hands, and a public broadcaster kept short of money and autonomy.
The remedy is the one the Supreme Court pointed to in 1995: use the airwaves for the public good, under an authority independent of government and of any single interest, with a strong public broadcaster at the heart of the system. Ask your Member of Parliament where they stand.
Sources
The law and the airwaves
- Ministry of Information and Broadcasting: Supreme Court judgment on the airwaves, 1995 (also on our site)
- LiveLaw, 1 May 2024: Supreme Court registry rejects the Centre’s 2G application
- Telecommunications Act, 2023, First Schedule
- Free Press Journal, 9 September 2026: 5% spectrum charge for satellite internet
- Guidelines for Uplinking and Downlinking of Television Channels in India, 2022
- PIB, 30 January 2023: advisory on the public service broadcasting obligation
- Vajiram & Ravi, June 2026: Draft Broadcasting Rules 2026 explained
- Odisha Bytes, 12 June 2026: a single rulebook for TV, radio and DTH
- The Week (PTI), 14 August 2025: FM stations awarded in 43 cities
- Storyboard18, 23 February 2026: 470–582 MHz band cleared for D2M
- Indian Television, 14 February 2026: government panel clears D2M broadcasting
Regulation and the media market
- LiveLaw, 14 August 2023: Supreme Court on penalties for TV channels
- Storyboard18, December 2025: broadcasting bill still under revision
- Indian Television, 14 March 2025: Parliament panel asks for a timeline for the broadcasting bill
- Storyboard18, 28 March 2026: TV Rating Policy 2026
- Business Today, 10 February 2026: labels for AI-generated content
- exchange4media, 28 August 2024: the Reliance–Disney combined assets
- SportCal, November 2024: Reliance–Disney merger completed
- Reporters Without Borders: India
- Newslaundry, 14 April 2022: TRAI seeks views on monitoring cross-media ownership
- Open, 25 March 2026: digital’s share of India’s media market
- Indian Television, 24 March 2026: FICCI-EY report on television households